Skip to main content

I'm going to offer this as a possibility, one that has some support in current science but that I find philosophically unpalatable enough that I'm not sold on it's truth:

Free will is an illusion, and we post-hoc narrate reasons for our actions.

So when your child answers he is answering honestly that he doesn't know because he isn't yet far enough along in his development to fabricate the kind of internal narrative an adult would.

In other words, none of us know and your son is just being more honest with himself (and you) than the rest of us.

That being said, I recommend that you encourage your son to stop and think before performing actions. Also regardless of the above argument for determinism, I disagree that a 7 year old is rationally calculating "oh if I do this I'll be punished, but it will be worth it": that's adults projecting their adult thinking on to a child.

References

In addition to the Scientific American article linked above:

Psychology Today

The Independent

The Atlantic article

Sam Harris, popular neuroscientist

I'm going to offer this as a possibility, one that has some support in current science but that I find philosophically unpalatable enough that I'm not sold on it's truth:

Free will is an illusion, and we post-hoc narrate reasons for our actions.

So when your child answers he is answering honestly that he doesn't know because he isn't yet far enough along in his development to fabricate the kind of internal narrative an adult would.

In other words, none of us know and your son is just being more honest with himself (and you) than the rest of us.

That being said, I recommend that you encourage your son to stop and think before performing actions. Also regardless of the above argument for determinism, I disagree that a 7 year old is rationally calculating "oh if I do this I'll be punished, but it will be worth it": that's adults projecting their adult thinking on to a child.

References

In addition to the Scientific American article linked above:

Psychology Today

The Independent

The Atlantic article

Sam Harris, popular neuroscientist

I'm going to offer this as a possibility, one that has some support in current science but that I find philosophically unpalatable enough that I'm not sold on it's truth:

Free will is an illusion, and we post-hoc narrate reasons for our actions.

So when your child answers he is answering honestly that he doesn't know because he isn't yet far enough along in his development to fabricate the kind of internal narrative an adult would.

In other words, none of us know and your son is just being more honest with himself (and you) than the rest of us.

That being said, I recommend that you encourage your son to stop and think before performing actions. Also regardless of the above argument for determinism, I disagree that a 7 year old is rationally calculating "oh if I do this I'll be punished, but it will be worth it": that's adults projecting their adult thinking on to a child.

References

In addition to the Scientific American article linked above:

Notice removed Needs citation by anongoodnurse
added 7 characters in body
Source Link
anongoodnurse
  • 72.2k
  • 15
  • 167
  • 266

I'm going to offer this as a possibility, one that accords withhas some support in current science but that I find philosophically unpalatable enough that I'm not sold on it's truth:

Free will is an illusion, and we post-hoc narrate reasons for our actions.

So when your child answers he is answering honestly that he doesn't know because he isn't yet far enough along in his development to fabricate the kind of internal narrative an adult would.

In other words, none of us know and your son is just being more honest with himself (and you) than the rest of us.

That being said, I recommend that you encourage your son to stop and think before performing actions. Also regardless of the above argument for determinism, I disagree that a 7 year old is rationally calculating "oh if I do this I'll be punished, but it will be worth it": that's adults projecting their adult thinking on to a child.

References

In addition to the Scientific American article linked above:

Psychology Today

The Independent

The Atlantic article

Sam Harris, popular neuroscientist

I'm going to offer this as a possibility, one that accords with current science but that I find philosophically unpalatable enough that I'm not sold on it's truth:

Free will is an illusion, and we post-hoc narrate reasons for our actions.

So when your child answers he is answering honestly that he doesn't know because he isn't yet far enough along in his development to fabricate the kind of internal narrative an adult would.

In other words, none of us know and your son is just being more honest with himself (and you) than the rest of us.

That being said, I recommend that you encourage your son to stop and think before performing actions. Also regardless of the above argument for determinism, I disagree that a 7 year old is rationally calculating "oh if I do this I'll be punished, but it will be worth it": that's adults projecting their adult thinking on to a child.

References

In addition to the Scientific American article linked above:

Psychology Today

The Independent

The Atlantic article

Sam Harris, popular neuroscientist

I'm going to offer this as a possibility, one that has some support in current science but that I find philosophically unpalatable enough that I'm not sold on it's truth:

Free will is an illusion, and we post-hoc narrate reasons for our actions.

So when your child answers he is answering honestly that he doesn't know because he isn't yet far enough along in his development to fabricate the kind of internal narrative an adult would.

In other words, none of us know and your son is just being more honest with himself (and you) than the rest of us.

That being said, I recommend that you encourage your son to stop and think before performing actions. Also regardless of the above argument for determinism, I disagree that a 7 year old is rationally calculating "oh if I do this I'll be punished, but it will be worth it": that's adults projecting their adult thinking on to a child.

References

In addition to the Scientific American article linked above:

Psychology Today

The Independent

The Atlantic article

Sam Harris, popular neuroscientist

Post Undeleted by Jared Smith
Post Deleted by Jared Smith
Post Undeleted by Jared Smith
Post Deleted by Jared Smith
added 581 characters in body
Source Link
Jared Smith
  • 1.3k
  • 1
  • 8
  • 15

I'm going to offer this as a possibility, one that accords with current science but that I find philosophically unpalatable enough that I'm not sold on it's truth:

Free will is an illusion, and we post-hoc narrate reasons for our actions.

So when your child answers he is answering honestly that he doesn't know because he isn't yet far enough along in his development to fabricate the kind of internal narrative an adult would.

In other words, none of us know and your son is just being more honest with himself (and you) than the rest of us.

That being said, I recommend that you encourage your son to stop and think before performing actions. Also regardless of the above argument for determinism, I disagree that a 7 year old is rationally calculating "oh if I do this I'll be punished, but it will be worth it": that's adults projecting their adult thinking on to a child.

References

In addition to the Scientific American article linked above:

Psychology Today

The Independent

The Atlantic article

Sam Harris, popular neuroscientist

I'm going to offer this as a possibility, one that accords with current science but that I find philosophically unpalatable enough that I'm not sold on it's truth:

Free will is an illusion, and we post-hoc narrate reasons for our actions.

So when your child answers he is answering honestly that he doesn't know because he isn't yet far enough along in his development to fabricate the kind of internal narrative an adult would.

In other words, none of us know and your son is just being more honest with himself (and you) than the rest of us.

That being said, I recommend that you encourage your son to stop and think before performing actions. Also regardless of the above argument for determinism, I disagree that a 7 year old is rationally calculating "oh if I do this I'll be punished, but it will be worth it": that's adults projecting their adult thinking on to a child.

I'm going to offer this as a possibility, one that accords with current science but that I find philosophically unpalatable enough that I'm not sold on it's truth:

Free will is an illusion, and we post-hoc narrate reasons for our actions.

So when your child answers he is answering honestly that he doesn't know because he isn't yet far enough along in his development to fabricate the kind of internal narrative an adult would.

In other words, none of us know and your son is just being more honest with himself (and you) than the rest of us.

That being said, I recommend that you encourage your son to stop and think before performing actions. Also regardless of the above argument for determinism, I disagree that a 7 year old is rationally calculating "oh if I do this I'll be punished, but it will be worth it": that's adults projecting their adult thinking on to a child.

References

In addition to the Scientific American article linked above:

Psychology Today

The Independent

The Atlantic article

Sam Harris, popular neuroscientist

Notice added Needs citation by anongoodnurse
deleted 4 characters in body
Source Link
Jared Smith
  • 1.3k
  • 1
  • 8
  • 15
Loading
Source Link
Jared Smith
  • 1.3k
  • 1
  • 8
  • 15
Loading