2

I have a 14 month old daughter and she has a 12 month cousin. We live in the same household and the issue here is that the 12M keeps pulling my daughters hair, pinching her, biting her for everything and my daughter doesn’t do anything. I say no with a stern voice but she doesn’t seem to understand.

1
  • Who else lives in the household? Is the cousin's mother at home? What (if anything) does she do when this happens? Have you discussed this behavior with her? – anongoodnurse Jun 9 at 14:24
8

At that age you are going to have a hard time teaching a child to fight back appropriately. There's too much nuance in when it's ok vs when it isn't (even adults debate this) for a 14 month old to fully grasp.

You are going to be far better served dealing with it yourself. Protect the children, separate them, console them. If they can't be trusted together, don't let them play together without close supervision and being physically within arm's reach.

You can also talk with your niece/nephew's parents to have them work with their child on learning to not hurt your child (or anyone for that matter). How to handle that is a whole new question that I won't address here. Regardless of what they do or don't do, your responsibility is to keep your child safe. Make that your highest priority. Learning self defense can come (much) later.

-1

You don't.

Both children are too young to even have a strong concept of "myself" and "other people", let alone "empathy", "fighting back" etc. At this moment in their development it's your responsibility as an adult to stop harmful behaviour by changing the situation. Distract them with something different. Take one child on your arm, to a different corner or into a different room.

What you can do, is starting to strengthen your child's idea of "myself" and their personal boundaries, by not just doing stuff to them, but asking for consent, e.g. when changing the diapers. But you must be ok with getting no for an answer to do that. If you do this, this might help along the way in a few years' time, but it won't make a difference in the short term.

Edit:

I'm happy to provide a short introduction to childhood development in the English Language: https://www.scholastic.com/teachers/articles/teaching-content/ages-stages-how-children-develop-self-concept/

My primary sources are

  • Remo H. Largo: Babyjahre
  • Nicola Schmidt: Der Elternkompass
  • Nora Imlau: Mein Familienkompass

Maybe this is some use for further reading to those speaking German.

Edit2:

As mentioned in a comment, the approach of asking for consent may lead to harmful situations, where you will have to decide, how far you are willing to go. I do believe that it will actively help your kid to learn to assert itself against violations against their private space, which I understand to be your goal. But you'll have to decide, if this is the right approach for you and your child.

9
  • Some studies show that empathy starts as early as in infancy. If the child is old enough to ask for things (like "more"), she has a sense of self. (What do you think would happen if she asked for more [e.g. milk], and her mother served her father instead? Confusion indicates a clear sense of self vs. other, and crying angrily or sadly could indicate a sense of right and wrong. You should really back these claims up with facts (if you could find them.) -1. – anongoodnurse Jun 9 at 0:02
  • @anongoodnurse It's true that some basic foundations of empathy develop or start to show early on. For the problem at hand the child has to be able to (1) differentiate between themselves and others and (2) understand that those others may experience things and feel differently from themselves. – Jan Niklas Fingerle Jun 9 at 0:58
  • I read the article (which was without a single respected source) and it does not fully support your answer. Do you really believe that at age 12 mos, there is no sense of me? – anongoodnurse Jun 9 at 1:45
  • 4
    I can't think that asking a baby for permission to change a diaper is a good idea. Tell them what is happening. Say things like "we are going to the supermarket now". Ask whether they want the blue coat or the red one. But asking if you can do something that is non-negotiable is just silly. They won't understand that the nappy rash has anything to do with their decision. – Paul Johnson Jun 9 at 12:59
  • 1
    The second paragraph ("its your responsibility") is fine. The rest is irrelevant. – Paul Johnson Jun 9 at 13:01

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.