2

My oldest daughter is 3. I'm trying to teach her how to read and write (in English).

My daughter can recite the alphabet A-Z, but cannot identify the letters. She can trace over letters that I write very lightly in pencil, but can't write letters on her own.

In the old-fashioned rote way of learning, if you want to learn a quotation, for example, you write it 100 times. So perhaps she would be better at identifying letters if she could write them.

Should I focus on having her identify the letters first? Or should I focus on having her write the letters on the page as a way to identify them? Which method is more effective at introducing literacy; or some other introductory method that I am not using?

  • 1
    I'm not a literacy expert by any means, but I would think you would need to be able to identify the letters first for writing them to have any meaning. Otherwise all she's doing is drawing pretty lines. Those lines could be a dog, a dump truck, a pancake or the letter A. If you can't tell them apart, what's the difference? – Becuzz Jul 29 at 16:30
4

I don't think there is a cut and dried answer to this; but my experience from a Montessori background is closer to write, but still not that either.

The difficulty with learning to write them is that writing is hard physically, the fine motor motions are difficult to make at that age.

In a Montessori environment, the Sandpaper Letters are the way they introduce letters. Note that they don't introduce them too early - 3 might be earlier than some would (the lesson I linked to said 4).

The idea of sandpaper letters is that you have physical letters that you can trace and feel - with sandpaper, or felt, or similar - but still on paper, not plastic cutouts or whatnot. You then say the sound of the letter ("buh", "duh", "guh", etc.) while tracing it with your finger. (Montessori prefers to teach sounds, not letter names, first, as that is the more important element of the letter, and avoids some confusing names like "double-u" or "aitch" or "gee" which don't really sound too much like their most common sound). And yes, the letters really are made from sandpaper cut out and pasted onto blocks of wood.

Here you're learning both, basically: you're learning to identify the letter while also learning in a physical sense. I (not an educator) always felt that this makes sense in the same way your write the quotation 100 times does - you experience it in multiple ways, particularly physical ways, to help reinforce the learning. That's one of the principles of Montessori learning - focusing on physically experiencing everything, math, letters, etc. - to effectively learn it.

You also focus on learning a few at a time - I like the suggestions of the link a bit below that you start with a few common letters plus the letters in the child's name, and do only 3 at a time until she's mastered those.

After that they then start working with the letters in the moveable alphabet, which is essentially similar to having alphabet magnets on your fridge.

Here's a good explanation of how to teach sandpaper letters, and a link to make them yourself also.

1

I suspect the answer is going to depend on her learning style. I doubt you know what her learning style is yet, so you should probably try a range of different approaches and see what sticks.

Writing or tracing the letters (even just with a finger) will be good for a physical learning style in which movement is particularly remembered.

On the other hand the "Letter Factory" video (extract here) will be good for visual and aural learning. This worked brilliantly for my son at that age.

Some children like to learn socially, interacting with a teacher or parent. On the other hand my son spent 2 weeks at kindergarten sitting alone and working his way through every program in a particular teaching toy (also by Leapfrog).

So in summary, try lots of different stuff and see what works.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.