2

I heard a violent argument between a mother and her child.

Obviously it was the child's mistake and he said something really really bad that must have hurt mother's feelings. His words made everybody around go ballistic also.

At that moment, the mother gave her bad son a big slap in the face. I believe that normal people would not be able to have good control over their feelings under such circumstance.

Her son, although looks like about ten years old, seemed to at least understand what a lawsuit is. He claimed that he would sue his mother.

Is "slapping a badly-behaved child" against the law in US? Will that mother be sent into jail ?

  • 3
    I'm voting to close this question as off-topic because it's a legal question and is explicitly off topic as per the help center. – Becuzz Nov 27 '17 at 13:30
6

It depends on the state and the circumstances. State law trumps federal law in most cases.See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporal_punishment_of_minors_in_the_United_States. In this case, it is probable that no law was broken, depending on the state.

3

There are a couple of different things in this post.

First an adult should never do anything to a child out of anger.

Second there are laws in the US against child abuse but not corporal punishment per say. So hitting with a fist and breaking a nose or fracturing a jaw would be child abuse, but an open handed slap that leaves a red mark would be within the limits.

Third the schools in the US started giving children "education" about child abuse trying to prevent such abuse - abuse which does happen to some kids. The schools have indoctrinated kids with your parents can't do this and they can't do that. Frankly I think that for small children whose language skills are not yet developed that a little swat on the fanny is a good thing. I also think that some mystery in life is good. (What would happen if my parents got so mad that they totally lost control...) But by the time a child is old enough to start school and be reasoned with, then methods other than corporal punishment should be used.

The "education" problem is a real pickle for adults today. My daughter pulled that on my wife and I. She said that she was going to call the police and report that she was being abused. You can't tell her that she can't call since that would throw gas on the fire. Fortunately I was able to think faster. Ok call. But I'm not leaving the house that I work to pay for. If anybody goes then you'll be removed to a group home until this matter is resolved. It will probably take a 3 or 4 months to resolve. So if that is what you want go ahead and try calling the police. (My daughter was a privileged princess and never abused in any way.)

  • I disagree with the "slap is ok" part, but this DOES actually explain how the kid could come to react like that. And yes, I agree that it does put parents in a pickle. So, slightly grouching +1. Technically off topic comment: I still vastly prefer putting parents into a pickle about how to react to that over having children at risk because they believe actual full-scale abuse is nor and/or accepted. – Layna Nov 27 '17 at 8:16
  • @Layna - I don't approve of slapping children either, but I don't think that it would be illegal in any state in the US unless the slap caused some significant damage like breaking an nose. – MaxW Nov 27 '17 at 8:42

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.