2

Recently saw a video by a nurse swinging a baby probably under 1 year holding baby's legs.

Is it safe to lift 7-month-old girl baby using the legs if the baby enjoys?

  • 1
    I am not finding any reliable sources that say it is okay, but it seems that actually being upside down (for a short period, IMO) is no more harmful than when it was happening in the womb. Kids like to be upside down, but in a playground, it lasts only a minute or less before they move on to another activity. We know we cannot lift a child by the arms until three years of age, and though I cannot find anything to back me up -- I'd bet if the child is being swung, s/he he is at higher risk. My 'gut' says this is not a great idea, but I never had a child at this stage of development. – WRX Apr 14 '17 at 13:24
  • 1
    I haven't done this to our baby but I do swing them up and down in a bit of an arc and he loves it. Saying that my baby seems to have zero fear at the moment. Big dog, older brother, daft daddy (me) seems to equal fearless baby. Will I swing him upside Using his legs? Probably not, only because I don't feel I have much control over them. Would it bother my baby if I did, probably not but that's not to say it should be done. I don't think it's a bad thing but I also don't think it's beneficial. – Bugs Apr 14 '17 at 17:46
  • 1
    @Bugs - Some babies love it. Adults love similar things: roller coasters, bungee jumping (which I will never, ever do), etc. – anongoodnurse Apr 14 '17 at 20:43
4

This depends somewhat on the baby's age and whether the baby has any problems with his hips. If a baby is cruising (standing holding on to furniture and taking steps this way), I don't think short periods of gentle upside down swinging is harmful; obviously, don't repeat if the baby isn't enjoying it. I would also add that it shouldn't be done if a baby has recently eaten.*

The hips are comparatively very stable joints; it's rare to dislocate a normal hip, whereas dislocated shoulders are common, and dislocated elbows are very, very common. That's because one of the pair of bones in the forearm, the radius, is incompletely formed still, and the ligaments still relatively weak, and do not protect from being pulled out of joint with force.

Nursemaid's elbow often occurs when a caregiver holds a child's hand or wrist and pulls suddenly on the arm to avoid a dangerous situation or to help the child onto a step or curb. The injury may also occur during play when an older friend or family member swings a child around holding just the arms or hands.

Nursemaid's elbow occurs when there is a partial separation of the radiocapitellar joint. Because a young child's ligaments - the strong tissues that attach bones to each other-are not fully formed, even a mild force on the joint may cause it to shift, or partially dislocate.

The annular ligament surrounds the radius and may be particularly loose in some young children, which may lead to nursemaid's elbow recurring over and over again.

Although the source mentions swinging a child by the arms, I have never seen a dislocation of this kind occur if this is done gently and properly (both hands - or wrists - at the same time.) Otherwise, with the popular "swing me" game (where the child is walking between the parents and asks to be swung) would result in many injuries.

Of course, this should be avoided in children who have already experiences a dislocated elbow (or more properly called a radial head subluxation, which is a partial dislocation) because the first recurrence rate is about 22%.

*My husband was doing this to our (maybe 6 month old) baby, who was loving it. I asked him to stop, I encouraged him to stop, I warned him to stop, but he didn't, until the child vomited in a large arc everywhere. He should have thought about it more. Common sense. But the baby was fine, if perhaps a little dizzy on returning to the proper upright position.

The hips are so stable normally that on delivery of sheep and goats, if the newborn animal is not breathing, one of the first things the 'midwife' (me, in my case) can do is to grab the newborn by the hind legs and forcefully swing in a full circle. This helps to clear liquid from the respiratory tract. NB: sheep and goat infants's hips are strong enough to withstand walking/weightbearing a very short time after birth.

Nursemaid's Elbow
Developmental Dislocation (Dysplasia) of the Hip (DDH)

  • 1
    I think a lot of people underestimate what the body can handle (even at a young age, probably even more so). For me it's not the baby I worry about when swinging them it's the fact I don't feel I have much control over them. In my years I've probably been thrown, dropped, fallen, squashed so many times I care to remember and I've yet to break a bone or have any problem from it. I think it's the vomit I'd be more concerned about :) – Bugs Apr 14 '17 at 17:52
1

The biggest risk I see is hitting the head on something (if swinging) or dropping the baby (head/neck injury). You might think you would never do that... but accidents do happen. Imagine you're holding her close to your face and you suddenly get a stream of vomit coming your way. It could be reflex to put her down a bit more quickly than you should.

So at that age I would only be comfortable doing it a very short distance above a soft surface, with slow movements and no hard objects nearby.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.