5

I'm looking for research papers and studies from disinterested (social) scientists, rather than magazine fluff-pieces or anything funded by the AMI or similar. The trivial google of "Montessori research" doesn't pull up much that passes the sniff-test.

  • You may check out the following on the research done on the benefits of Montessori schooling - public-montessori.org/resources/… and freepatentsonline.com/article/… – Yogi Sep 7 '16 at 4:38
  • 2
    I don't count anything on montessori.org as "disinterested", sorry. The other is interesting though, thanks. – Robert Atkins Sep 7 '16 at 8:40
  • "I don't count anything on montessori.org as 'disinterested', sorry." You obviously don't know how research works. – user7953 Sep 7 '16 at 10:23
  • 3
    There's a difference between "how research should work" and "how research usually works". – Erik Sep 7 '16 at 11:44
  • 1
    Yes, research has been done. Tracking children years later, there are academic benefits for boys. For girls, there are no academic benefits, but there are social benefits in terms of self confidence. This is consistent with my experience with my own kids; the girl's speech improved due to being in a social situation, but she chose to spend all her time in the home ec section - possibly guided by unconscious prejudices of the teachers - so she didn't get the benefits of the more academically oriented sections, as the boy did. I'll post this as an answer if I can easily find the references. – Warren Dew Sep 7 '16 at 12:22
3

I have done dozens of hours of research on Montessori, but I've never come across any scientific studies, per se, so whether or not what I say is what you're looking for will be up to you. I agree with the previous answer, though, that how to raise your child should not solely be based on research papers, BUT - it should be based on evidence, to a degree. You can search up and down, far and wide, for valid, legitimate studies and research papers, but ultimately your best bet will be to study and get to know the method itself. It is absolutely possible to find unbiased, detailed information about Montessori herself, the pedagogy, and the current implementations in schools today in the US.

I will say, that after my studies, I hired a nanny when my son was born who was a former Montessori infant/toddler teacher. I promise I am not one of those parents who just thinks their child is some magical, gifted prodigy, but I believe Montessori principles have been very good for him. He is two and a half now, and while I obviously can't state any true long term effects of Montessori on him directly, I can say he is more capable in practical life than any other 2 year old I have encountered personally. That's not to say there aren't kids out there that are more capable than he, but the beauty of Montessori is it very much emphasizes teaching children to do things themselves based on their capabilities. That said, he can only barely count, and doesn't yet know his alphabet. But he throws away his own trash, puts his dishes in the sink, wipes up spills, prepares his own snacks, helps cook, dresses himself, was potty trained at 18 months without any types of rewards/bribes, etc. I consider those things life skills that are every bit as valuable as knowing your ABCs (and I've never met an adult who didn't know his colors, but I have met an 8 year old who had never been shown how to crack an egg into a bowl).

Instead of baby proofing, for instance, we create a "yes" environment. It is technically child proof, in the sense that it is safe, but nothing is off-limits. In other words, chemicals and things that could harm them are moved far out of reach (like way up high in a closet or cabinet), and things that are fine for them to access (like pots and pans) are left in lower cabinets, where they are free to explore. Children under the Montessori philosophy are treated as an equal member of the household. They are respected in the same way an adult wishes to be respected. That doesn't mean they get to do everything an adult gets to do, of course, there are limits and boundaries, but they are logical instead of arbitrary and defined by society.

Contrary to popular belief, academia as we tend to think of it is not the focus of Montessori's principles. In fact, if you look at her "10 commandments" (for lack of a better term), not a single one of them refer to academics. Now, granted her teachings involve formal academics - math, science, language, etc. - but the Montessori philosophy is so much more than that, so it can't be compared directly with, say, a normal public elementary school.

Which is another thing that makes it very difficult to create a scientific study. What would you be looking for? Grades? Academic assessments? Overall achievements? The point of Montessori isn't to make sure a child excels at math or reading. The point is that you follow the child's lead. You don't treat every child equally, because their personalities, their temperaments, their interests, are vastly different from one another. You don't sit 20 of them in a classroom and teach them all the exact same thing, give them the exact same tests, and expect them to score the exact same grade at the exact same time. Some children learn faster than others, some are more skilled at reading than math, some are more interested in science than language. Montessori knew that all children would eventually learn these things (and others), if shown via repetition and with respect, via their absorbent mind. But her goal was to empower children to learn them in their own time, and to not attempt to compare their progress in one area with other children of the same age.

Finally, I think the most important thing is to know that Montessori is not all or nothing. Plenty of kids who go to Montessori schools don't live Montessori-inspired lives at home, and plenty of kids who have a Montessori home life don't go to Montessori schools. You would have to get to know the method to find out which principles are right for you and your family. For my family, my son now goes to a daycare which isn't anywhere near Montessori, and that's okay. We are still a Montessori household, as I am a very big fan of the fundamental principles of respecting our children to the utmost degree, and teaching them to be independent in their thinking, to lead by example, and to be gracious towards others.

** Just adding one more thing, in Montessori, there is no such thing as punishment for "bad" behavior, nor reward for "good" behavior. This is something that trips up a lot of parents, and it did me at first, but the more I researched child development / child psychology alongside, the more her views on this aligned with many major life-span psychologists. That there is truly no benefit to punishing children; that it doesn't teach them anything and that time and energy are better spent on preparing their environment and teaching them about their surroundings, and redirecting unwanted behavior. Again, I bring it up, because it's something a LOT of parents hone in on and decide they can't function as parents if they can't put their child in time-out.

  • I notice you say "we create a "yes" environment" Are you affiliated with a Montessori School? – rbreier Oct 7 '16 at 21:30
  • I'm not affiliated with any Montessori organizations, no. By "we", I just mean Montessorians in general - those of us who apply Montessori principles in our homes. – user24720 Oct 7 '16 at 21:41
3

Chapter 7 of How To Raise an Adult by Julie Lythcott-Haims refers to a few studies that addresses the unstructured play vs structured play, which Montessori seems to favor more over very rigidly defined activities. Unstructured play (not totally, but within reason) boosts executive brain function which helps them determine which action to take to achieve their goals. (http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpsyg.2014.00593/full) Kids with better executive brain function generally do better in school and life. http://developingchild.harvard.edu/science/key-concepts/executive-function/

That's what jumped out at me so far having made it to chapter 9. It's a good book so far.

Montessori also teaches social skills, which sure seem to be lacking in many kids today. As someone who hires people, I'd rather hire someone with good social and professional skills.

My son is in a Montessori school now (for two years) and I can see that it doesn't fit well with some kids' temperaments and learning types. I don't think any one-size-fits-all learning approach will work for all kids regardless.

1

I see that this question has generated interest without an actual answer provided. The required sample size to do a study like this is quite large and the length of time needed to truly evaluate the benefits of a school is a lifetime. Also, there are so many contributing factors that will determine the success of a person from schooling until death. Many factors even outweigh the impact of schooling on a person.

With that being said, I believe that it is not feasible to conduct a scientific study. But that will not stop people from doing so and producing results to the general public, like the fluff pieces you mention. I think that by being concerned about what school to send your children, you are demonstrating that you will try to give your child a successful future. That is great. I would suggest that you take any studies or research with a grain of salt on this matter.

If there was an equation to determine the future level of success of a child, almost every parent would be doing it, thereby nullifying the equation.

Also, define 'benefits'. What may seem like a benefit in the short term can be a detriment over the long term.

As a parent, you already know what is best for your child. Your gut tells you. I would suggest going with your gut and leave the research papers on "How to educate/raise/discipline your child" out of your parental decisions.

  • 1
    I don't really agree with the last paragraph. Most parents have a pretty good handle on good ways to raise their children, especially if they are ones willing to read studies and such but I think there are still valuable papers out there on various learning methods (you may need to try a way that didn't work for you or you weren't familiar with), methods of comfort, discipline, sleep training, etc that you may not think or someone has learned after dealing with 10s or 100s of children etc. Just because you conceive a child doesn't make you all of a sudden all knowing about child welfare. – gtwebb Oct 6 '16 at 22:05
  • I suppose it is just a matter of personal experience. I am confident that anyone reading this is fully capable of making wise choices, and if it proves to be a mistake, they will make adjustments. It's okay if you don't agree. – rbreier Oct 7 '16 at 1:15

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.