Skip to main content
updated tags (age, "misbehavior" is asking for the root of misbehavior)
Source Link

Three weeks ago while visiting relatives, my seven year old nephew (who is generally terribly behaved) was particularly nasty to my two year old daughter.

Amongst the issues was him refusing to share his toys with her. After failing with gentle coersioncoercion, I told him that she wouldn't be sharing her bouncy castle (which he loves) when he next visits us. This also failed to persuade him, and we left with a teary daughter with me feeling frustrated that I'd lost the battle.

He's due to visit us in a few days, and I wondered whether I should enforce what I said to him that day?

My thoughts are:

  • Two wrongs don't make a right
  • I don't want my daughter seeing further tantrums or bad behaviour as a result of this situation

But on the contrary:

  • He should respect authority, and
  • Understand the consquences of his actions

I realise there's probably no concrete answer to this, but would appreciate any input where others have faced the same situation, and come out feeling that the siutation was resolved properly, for everyone's benefit, or at least the child saw the error of their ways.

Three weeks ago while visiting relatives, my seven year old nephew (who is generally terribly behaved) was particularly nasty to my two year old daughter.

Amongst the issues was him refusing to share his toys with her. After failing with gentle coersion, I told him that she wouldn't be sharing her bouncy castle (which he loves) when he next visits us. This also failed to persuade him, and we left with a teary daughter with me feeling frustrated that I'd lost the battle.

He's due to visit us in a few days, and I wondered whether I should enforce what I said to him that day?

My thoughts are:

  • Two wrongs don't make a right
  • I don't want my daughter seeing further tantrums or bad behaviour as a result of this situation

But on the contrary:

  • He should respect authority, and
  • Understand the consquences of his actions

I realise there's probably no concrete answer to this, but would appreciate any input where others have faced the same situation, and come out feeling that the siutation was resolved properly, for everyone's benefit, or at least the child saw the error of their ways.

Three weeks ago while visiting relatives, my seven year old nephew (who is generally terribly behaved) was particularly nasty to my two year old daughter.

Amongst the issues was him refusing to share his toys with her. After failing with gentle coercion, I told him that she wouldn't be sharing her bouncy castle (which he loves) when he next visits us. This also failed to persuade him, and we left with a teary daughter with me feeling frustrated that I'd lost the battle.

He's due to visit us in a few days, and I wondered whether I should enforce what I said to him that day?

My thoughts are:

  • Two wrongs don't make a right
  • I don't want my daughter seeing further tantrums or bad behaviour as a result of this situation

But on the contrary:

  • He should respect authority, and
  • Understand the consquences of his actions

I realise there's probably no concrete answer to this, but would appreciate any input where others have faced the same situation, and come out feeling that the siutation was resolved properly, for everyone's benefit, or at least the child saw the error of their ways.

Tweeted twitter.com/StackParenting/status/862898080483602432
edited title
Link
EvilDr
  • 829
  • 2
  • 10
  • 16

Do I enforce a punishment/rertributionretribution promised some time ago?

Source Link
EvilDr
  • 829
  • 2
  • 10
  • 16

Do I enforce a punishment/rertribution promised some time ago?

Three weeks ago while visiting relatives, my seven year old nephew (who is generally terribly behaved) was particularly nasty to my two year old daughter.

Amongst the issues was him refusing to share his toys with her. After failing with gentle coersion, I told him that she wouldn't be sharing her bouncy castle (which he loves) when he next visits us. This also failed to persuade him, and we left with a teary daughter with me feeling frustrated that I'd lost the battle.

He's due to visit us in a few days, and I wondered whether I should enforce what I said to him that day?

My thoughts are:

  • Two wrongs don't make a right
  • I don't want my daughter seeing further tantrums or bad behaviour as a result of this situation

But on the contrary:

  • He should respect authority, and
  • Understand the consquences of his actions

I realise there's probably no concrete answer to this, but would appreciate any input where others have faced the same situation, and come out feeling that the siutation was resolved properly, for everyone's benefit, or at least the child saw the error of their ways.