Take the 2-minute tour ×
Parenting Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for parents, grandparents, nannies and others with a parenting role. It's 100% free, no registration required.

That's the question.
What qualities should be looked in a bedding for an infant to prevent the crib deaths?

Does sealing the bedding with a strong polythene sheet provide any benefits or risks?

share|improve this question
6  
I don't think you'll find general acceptance of the accuracy of your quoted material. Soft mattresses and pillows, and sleeping face down, have been demonstrated as far more likely causes. The Back To Sleep public awareness campaign reduced the incidence of crib death in North America, as did the reduced incidence of smoking in homes. –  Chrys Mar 30 '13 at 15:43
5  
I would not put plastic or a pillow anywhere near a sleeping infant. Don't seal the pillow because you shouldn't have a pillow. Don't seal the mattress either. –  Chrys Mar 30 '13 at 17:40
5  
@AnishaKaul The source you listed claims to know factually what the source of crib death is, yet all authoritative references agree that, by definition, the cause is unknown. My suggestion would be to edit out that controversial part at the beginning, and focus your question on what your goals are (i.e. how you should wrap the mattress), but I will leave that up to you. –  Beofett Mar 30 '13 at 19:42
2  
To expand upon Chrys' last comment, according to extensive research, pillows are one of the leading risk factors for SIDS. –  Beofett Mar 30 '13 at 19:46
4  
If you have concerns about the quality or chemistry of "standard" mattress materials, you can buy organic mattresses that are stuffed with cotton/wool rather than synthetic foam. Sheets/blankets should be lightweight and breathable. No pillows or large stuffed animals, or deep, fluffy, fleecy blankets. –  Erica Mar 31 '13 at 23:38

3 Answers 3

up vote 6 down vote accepted

The American Academy of Pediatrics has specific recommendations for infant bedding, with the goal of reducing instances of SIDS (a.k.a. "crib death" or "cot death"):

  • Always place your baby on his or her back for every sleep time.

  • Always use a firm sleep surface. Car seats and other sitting devices are not recommended for routine sleep.

  • Keep soft objects or loose bedding out of the crib. This includes pillows, blankets, and bumper pads.

  • Wedges and positioners should not be used.

  • Avoid covering the infant’s head or overheating.

These recommendations are those repeated by many reputable health care and pediatric groups, and are commonly recognized as the standard best-practices in modern pediatrics.

Does sealing the bedding with a strong polythene sheet provide any benefits or risks?

This is the recommendation associated with a rather controversial, and disputed, theory. Starting with Barry Richardson's 1989 "Richardson Hypothesis", and later continued by Dr. Jim Sprott, the hypothesis theorizes that certain fungi can break down some specific chemicals present in some children's bedding material, and convert it to "toxic 'nerve' gasses". The suggested solution to this is to wrap the mattress in special materials to prevent this "toxic nerve gas" from reaching the baby.

This theory has been studied several times, and the studies have shown that there is no evidence to substantiate this theory.

Dr. Sprott continues to support this theory, however, and claims it to be scientific "fact", rather than a theory (in my personal opinion, this is one of the big danger signs warning of quackery: no scientific theory is ever proven as "fact", and stating a minority opinion as "fact" is quite telling, imo). This is based upon his campaign to wrap mattresses in New Zealand, and an overall decrease in "cot death" fatalities (again, a correlation of this nature is far too weak an argument to declare a theory as confirmed, imo).

Here is a discussion about the theory that brings up some good points. Mainly that Dr. Sprott directly profits from this theory, since he apparently markets both his own line of "approved" mattress covers as the "cure to SIDS", and also his own book on the subject.

On Dr. Sprott's website, he makes quite clear that only his product is safe (the FAQ mentions several times that other covers are not safe, citing repeatedly his "Cot Life 2000" protocol, which apparently states that all types of materials must be enclosed in his patented cover; note that I can find no evidence that the government of New Zealand in any way endorses this "protocol").

Under no circumstances do I think any parent should undertake to wrap their child's mattress in their own polythene sheet; it seems even Dr. Sprott does not feel this is safe to do as a "DIY" project.

share|improve this answer

all the guidance we got suggests that putting plastic wrapping anywhere near a mattress is a very bad idea. Like Chrys says, you do not get 'nerve gases' from mattresses, and in fact letting air get through a mattress is a much better idea.

Babies should not have a pillow, but should be laid on the mattress, with one breathable blanket under them.

This breathability allows them to breathe if they do roll onto their front. It also allows spittle, milk and vomit to move away from baby's mouth!

share|improve this answer

In my opinion, "sealing the bedding with a strong polythene sheet" presents a significant risk of suffocation -- not SIDS, just plain asphyxiation. Most infant mattresses are deliberately covered with a mesh webbing underneath the cotton surface with the explicit purpose of allowing the baby to breathe even if it turns face-down during sleep.

Try it for yourself: bury your face in your own pillow and try to breathe. It's neither easy nor comfortable, but you survive. Now wrap a plastic bag around your pillow and repeat -- you'll notice that it's completely impossible to breathe!

For this simple reason, any and all material in and near an infant's bed must be a "breathable" type. Baby pillows, bedsheets and teddy bears present a suffocation danger simply because they might end up in front of the baby's face during the night.


Frankly, the text in the source originally stated in your question is scary, but really the scary thing is that some human being wrote that text and seems to believe that baby mattresses really contain "highly toxic nerve gases." Why would there be phosphorus or even arsenic in a mattress? Such stupidity! Please please never believe such panic-mongering. You were right to doubt that text. I'm glad you posted your question!

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.